Location: BlogsCherokee Blog    
Posted by: Tom Daniels 10/5/2008 11:12 PM
One of the things that’s a little disconcerting when you look at the boat at this point in time, is realizing that almost everything that you see in front of you, is temporary.

The molds are just there to guide the shape of the ribbands.  The ribbands are just there to make a surface for the frames to bend up against.  It all gets tossed. Lots of work there…

Ok, if the Buddhist monks can sweep up their sand mandalas as soon as they finish them,


well, I suppose that we can toss out some boat parts once they’ve served their purpose.

On to steaming!

The process of bending in frames is simplicity itself.  However, like everything else we do here, it involves a lot of steps to get to that simple, final act of putting a hot frame into the boat.

Before any frames get installed, we mark exactly where the frames should end up on the inside of ribbands.


We want the ribs to go straight up from the sockets in the keel, along the sides of the boat, and end up against the sheer (i.e., the top) ribband at a point that is plumb to the socket. If you were to look at the frames from the side, they would appear to rise straight up from the keel to the sheer.

Seems simple enough…The problem is that the ribbands are curving both upwards and towards both ends of the boat.  There’s no way to accurately hold a straight edge against them, you can’t drop a plumb bob down against a curved surface, and you can’t hold a level against a curved surface either.

So, how do you set up that vertical line on such a curvy surface?  

Actually, there’s a bunch of ways, ranging from just marking the location of the top of the frame along your sheer using information from your lofting and basically eyeballing the frame as you bend it in, to using a nifty laser like we did.  

We borrowed a laser level that shoots a perfectly flat line that sweeps almost 180 degrees.  Essentially, it creates a very accurate planar surface with light.  We used it to connect an edge of the socket with each of the frame locations at the port and starboard sheer. If you remember your geometry, you know that connecting any 3 points defines a plane.  When the beam touches the 2 sheer frame locations and the socket, it shines along a perfectly flat plane all the way up the inside faces of the ribbands.  We just mark where the light hits each ribband with a pen, and now we know where the edge of the frame will lie on the ribbands when it is going exactly straight up. 

But that’s not as exciting as steaming.

We cook our frames in this nice little steam box setup at 212 degrees for approximately 1 hr / inch of wood thickness.

No, it's not a still for making 'shine. That's over in the fort.

The water comes from a garden hose and goes into the bottomof the black bucket you see hanging there, and into a toilet tank float mechanism.  The float keeps the water in the bucket at a constant level.  When a little water drains out, the float level drops and allows some more water in from the hose.  

This is important because of a good old physics fact: Water seeks its own level.

We have a 2nd hose that connects the bucket to our boiler.  Since the bucket and boiler are connected, the water in the bucket will flow to the boiler until the two are at the same water level. The red line shows the water level between the two. 

This is handy, because as the water in the boiler turns to steam and heads up the tube into the steam box, the water level in the boiler drops.  If we didn’t have this nifty little bucket setup, we’d have to keep adding more water to the boiler to keep it from running dry.  

Of course, each time we did that, the cold water would stop the boiling and we wouldn’t get a good, constant source of steam for our frames.  The setup adds just a squirt of water as the level drops a bit, and the hot water in the boiler isn’t affected at all.  This allows us to have a steady supply of steam as long as the burner is on. 

Ok, enough on why you should have paid attention during science and math classes.

Once the inside of the ribbands are marked, and the steambox is going, it’s time to add frames to the mix.

We made a lot of frames. Each one is numbered so that we know where it goes, and each one is cut to a length that will allow it fit into it’s specific location with a little extra length to work with. There are some extras cut as well, since we assumed that at least of a few of them would break during installation.

We moved the steam box so that it faced the side door.  This makes it easy to get hot frames into the boat with minimal delay.

The frames begin to cool the second that they come out ofthe box, and a cool frame is a stiff frame. We want to reduce the time from box to boat as much as possible.

Once a frame has cooked long enough, we pull it from the box,

dip the bottom end into oil to help seal the end grain,

and pass it up to two guys inside the boat.

They press the frame out against the ribbands

as we pull from the outside.

Once the frame is bent up against the ribbands, we clamp itinto place.

After installing a few frames, we came up with a way to get the oil a little higher up the frame. We filled a length of pvc pipe with oil and used that as our dipping source rather than using the can.

Once the frames are hot, this whole process goes very quickly.  

Run in with a frame

Do a quick pre-bend across your knee

Dip in the oil

Pass the frame up, and guide the bottom of the frame into the socket

While one of the guys inside the boat hammers it home into the the socket from above.

Clamp the frames in quickly before they cool

Repeat, 138 times.

Not all frames can handle this kind of abuse.

Mostly these problems were due to the severe bends at the forward and aft sections of the boat. Some of the frames were cut from wood that had been a little too dry, and this made them brittle. That's what we think happened in the top frame that broke right across the grain. Others had grain that ran from the middle of the frame out to the edges, and those broke along that grain line. You can see that in the lower 2 frames.

As the first day of framing continued, the number of casualties rose.

The frames had to make a substantial bend near the ends of the boat, and they didn’t want to stay in their sockets without some assistance.

Here you can see that the frame nearest to the camera is coming out of its socket.

Right behind that frame you can see that we’ve held the next frame in the socket with a metal plate.

Robin came up with this plate as a way to hold the frame into the socket while we bent it into place.  This plate has the added advantage of providing an access hole to screw the frame into the socket once it’s cooled down a bit.

That goop is bedding compound (Dolphinite). We drill our pilot hole with the plate still on,

And drive the screw in as well

before removing the plate. It worked like a charm.

Once the frames have cooled down, we can replace the clamps with cable ties.

These are relatively cheap, easy to install, and they hold the frames solidly in place until we screw the planking into them.

A little tuck neatens things up and helps us to not get poked in the eye.

As framing progresses, the boat fills out just a little bit.

And really starts to look like a basket.

In some places, the frames didn’t make the turn as well as we wanted, so we did a little spot steaming to soften them up.

We then used small blocks and clamps to push them exactly into the curves where they belonged.

And in a few days, we were just about finished.

Some of the frames at the aft end of the boat gave us a lot of trouble.  At one point we were breaking five frames for every one that went in. We think it was probably a batch of wood that wasn’t as green as some of our other stock. When you’re bending in frames, the greener the wood, the better.

But, perseverance furthers, and at last we bent in the final frame.

Whew!

No time to rest on our laurels, however.  There’s planking to be done, and the days are getting a little cooler in our unheated shop.

Special thanks this week go to Anna and Jason for their help in getting the framing going, and we all thank Holly for taking so many of the photos used in this entry.

Permalink |  Trackback

Comments (10)   Add Comment
Re: Let’s get steaming!    By Bob Easton on 10/6/2008 10:11 AM
(Favorite deity), please bless Holly for taking so many great photos! The more the better.

Anyone mentioned yet that it's a fabulous looking boat?!

Let's hope there's no more hearing the crack of breaking frames.

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By TomDaniels on 10/6/2008 10:16 AM
Yes indeed, she is a very nice looking boat. And I'll make sure to pass on the blessings to Holly. I think she prefers to be blessed with apple pie.

As of today, we've found 2 frames that developed stress fractures, so we'll be replacing them today. One of them is a frame that had been spot steamed to get that extra bend in the tuck, so we now know to make sure that that frame gets clamped in that area from the get go. Otherwise, things are looking great.

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By JOe W on 10/7/2008 7:16 AM
Smashing Boat, Great Blog. I have a Question. What Oil are you using to dip the frames in.

Oil dip    By TomDaniels on 10/7/2008 7:27 AM
We use General Finishes' Outdoor Oil. David uses it a lot on the bright finished interiors of boats up at Boothbay Harbor Shipyard, and it holds up well to the elements. You have to watch out for the typical problems associated with using oil, however, such as rags spontaneously combusting if left in a pile.

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By Duncan Hannah on 10/8/2008 6:04 PM
Beautiful boat, great blog, by the way. I was getting used to looking at the molds as the boat took shape and now the frames look awfully small. Awfully small. I'm trying to see the boat without the molds and without the ribbands and it looks pretty light. Does the planking provide more than just a cover: does it work with the frames to provide more strenght than is apparent?

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By TomDaniels on 10/8/2008 6:54 PM
Duncan,
You're absolutely correct, the planking works with the framing as an integral structural element. These boats were built to be light, but the class rules give minimum sizes for (called "scantlings") for the various parts of the boat to prevent builders from making super light and essentially unsafe boats.

And here's a fun fact: not only is the planking a structural element, the caulking is as well! When you drive the cotton caulking into the seams between the planks, it exerts pressure on the planking and the whole affair tightens up like a drum. This makes the boat stiffer and stronger.

Boats, and race boats in particular, really are studies in efficient engineering.

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By Matt Cockburn on 10/14/2008 12:05 PM
Hi Tom,

You imply above that you'll be using cotton caulk. I was under the impression that you were going to use a "tight seam" method for the planking.

The boat looks great!

Thanks,
Matt

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By TomDaniels on 10/14/2008 12:14 PM
Hi Matt,
Nope, it's caulking for us. What we DO want to do, however, is to make sure that the planks meet as tightly as possible along their seam behind the caulking. You can't go wrong with multiple lines of defense. The water is kept out by (in more or less this order): paint, seam putty, caulking (also soaked in paint), and the wood-to-wood fit of the planking. Water is also kept from coming in the screw holes by bungs that are glued in place and the sealer that we dip the screws in.

And even after all that, some guy forgets to put the fenders on the boat in his haste to tie the boat up and get on to the Dark and Stormy party, and the hull gets breached as the boat bangs against the dock all night. We don't really have a layer to protect against that situation.

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By h. ventura on 10/16/2008 9:42 PM
I`ve been "following" the moy for years, and i´m very pleased to see that the information about boat building techniques are now shown in detail. That`s an excelent way of preserving " the art of the boat", not only at the east cost of the united states but around the world, in places that you can hardly think about.I visited the MOY in 2003, and I hope this project will became stronger and stronger. considering boats and their building techniques cultural heritage, is an example that we have been following in my home town - Ovar, Portugal.

Re: Let’s get steaming!    By TomDaniels on 10/16/2008 9:47 PM
Thank you, Ovar. Wow, following this all the way from Portugal! Your English is a lot better than my Spanish... I agree about the value of letting people know about these techniques. There are many people who are curious about how boats are built, and perhaps this can inspire a few of them to try it out for themselves! We'll try to keep it as accurate and informative as we can.


Your name:
Title:
Comment:
Add Comment   Cancel